See here for
essential background: https://hpanwo-voice.blogspot.com/2021/11/chimera.html.
I was keen to read the original 1982 novel of the TV series, also penned by Stephen Gallagher. Books are normally better than their adaptations, for example: https://hpanwo-hpwa.blogspot.com/2023/02/paper-mask-book.html, but not in this case. The plot varies significantly despite having the same author. A lot of the action from the TV series takes place as flashbacks and the narrative begins effectively about when episode two of the TV story does. The setting isCumbria ,
not North Yorkshire ; I don't know why that detail was
changed. The biggest difference is that the novel is far less emotional; it
lacks the human interest that the TV series does. Peter and Tracy are steady
couple on TV, whereas in the book the two have only known each other for a
short time and have gone on a couple of dates. As a result Tracy
is an unseen character, as is Marie Forester who does not attend the Jenner
Clinic and so does not die in the disaster. Dr Jenner himself is every bit as
much the narcissist and megalomaniac well played by David Calder in the TV
programme; an excellent antagonist. By contrast, Hennessey is a more
light-hearted and almost farcical character in the book. He lacks the
bureaucratic menace of Kenneth Cranham's portrayal. Dr Liawski is dead in the
book. It was actually quite a good idea to resurrect him for the TV programme,
so giving the classic actor Sebastian Shaw one last movie. Despite this, Liawski
does appear at the start as a young man in a rather incongruous prologue scene.
He then goes on to provide the information posthumously through his diaries
which are found by Peter Carson. The role of Alison Wells is far more morally
ambiguous in the book and she deceives Peter in a far worse manner. The ending
is completely different and, although not happy exactly, it is far less
apocalyptic. Chad
is far more animalistic and his human side does not really come out at all. He
manipulates and tricks the Gaskell children in a way that makes it difficult to
sympathize with him. Still, the book is worth reading and comparing by fans of
Gallagher's TV series.
See here for more information: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2020/08/ben-emlyn-jones-live-at-truth-seekers.html.
I was keen to read the original 1982 novel of the TV series, also penned by Stephen Gallagher. Books are normally better than their adaptations, for example: https://hpanwo-hpwa.blogspot.com/2023/02/paper-mask-book.html, but not in this case. The plot varies significantly despite having the same author. A lot of the action from the TV series takes place as flashbacks and the narrative begins effectively about when episode two of the TV story does. The setting is
See here for more information: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2020/08/ben-emlyn-jones-live-at-truth-seekers.html.
No comments:
Post a Comment