I have attended a live webinar by the Centre for Inquiry, a skeptic organization. It was a presentation by a researcher called Kenny Biddle about the life and works of Harry Houdini, the escapologist, illusionist and skeptic. This Halloween just gone is the centenery of his death. The hostess was a comedienne called Leighann Lord. Kenny gave a brief biography of Houdini, real name Erik Weisz, and how he became enraged by the presence of mediums, clairvoyants, fortune tellers and mystics, whom he denounced as frauds. He believed they were merely doing the same illusions as he was, but pretended to be real; as well as charging a lot of money for their chicanery. He had personal reasons for his mission, having suffered the loss of his father in 1892 and his mother in 1913. He was grief-stricken and sympathized with others who sought comfort from psychics and, as he asserted, were being exploited by them. He carried out scientitific investigations on mediums in psychical research laboratories and even offered people a cash prize if they could pass this challenge. It's obvious that this was where James Randi gained his inspiration. In around 1920 Houdini published a photograph of himself with US President Abraham Lincoln. A few people thought it was Lincoln's ghost, seeing as the president had been shot almost sixty years earlier. Harry wanted to demonstrate how photographs could be faked. Oddly enough some people didn't believe he was just doing tricks and thought that it was a double-bluff. He was truly psychic and was pretending not to be. This caused his old friend Arthur Conan Doyle to turn against him. Kenny then brought up a subject I have also covered, the message from Arthur Ford, see: https://hpanwo.blogspot.com/2009/05/houdini-code.html. Kenny provided an update. According to him, this is not as mysterious as it first appears. The code was not completely secure and Ford could have found out about it though non-paranormal means. Whether he did or not is unknown, but there's no doubt this is not a compltely watertight test and Bess eventually rejected it. I was impressed, nonetheless, that somebody else had come across this extremely obscure piece of information. Harry wrote a book in 1924 called A Magician Among the Spirits, see: https://archive.org/details/1924HoudiniAMagicianAmongTheSpirits/mode/2up. This must have again inspired Randi to name his book A Magician in the Laboratory, which he unfortunately never finished. According to a pact they made, Harry's wife, Bess, attended a seance every Halloween for ten years at the Knickerbocker Hotel in Los Angeles. The final one in 1936 was a huge public event with lights, fireworks and a crowd in the rooftop garden. Harry never came through. Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DfxQX5x7lIE.
I found it interesting that Houdini used to infiltrate seances and spiritualist conferences with a spy. He was far too famous to go along himself. He was targeted with a lot of hostility from the paranormal community and as recently as 1975 his grave was vandalized. He would have been kicked out of any psychic convention he turned up at. Therefore he collaborated with a number of unknown people who sneaked in undercover and gathered information. The most regular of these agents was Rose Mackenburg, a private investigator. She posed a grieving widow seeking messages from her dead husband. I find it ironic that I was now kind of doing the same thing, in a way, in the opposite direction. I was an illicit woo-woo gatecrashing this skeptic webinar. Technically speaking I was not a spy because I attended under my own identity, in fact you can see my comments in the livechat using my usual YouTube account. If anybody there recognized me they didn't tell me. To be fair, I've gone to many skeptic events, like QED con, see the background link below. So far nobody has ever objected to my presence, in fact I've only ever been banned from one conference, and that was a woo-woo one, see: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2023/05/a-person-goes-to-olm-one-year-on.html. In this case LeighAnn even highlighted some of my comments on screen! Mind you, I was not confrontational. I generally do not get into arguments at skeptics events; I just go along to gain information. There were about a dozen other people in the live chat and, as you can see from my comments, I just posted conversational statements only. I did make one joke, and the reaction to it was revealing. At about seventeen minutes in I posted: "He (Arthur Conan Doyle) believed the Cottingley Fairies. He didn't understand how photos could be faked. How would he cope with modern AI!?" Another viewer, somebody called "@TheVicar", presumably not an official title, replied: "by knowing AI existed and how easy it would be to produce fakes." I felt like replying with one of those memes of somebody looking up above their head as the word "JOKE" flies past out of their reach. Maybe it's because @TheVicar is a skepper and I'm not, but I didn't think my humour was all that subtle; but, as the late great Frankie Howerd used to say: "please yourselves!" In the Q&A somebody called "@JimDetwiler750" asked: "Question: Are you familiar with the Ganzfeld procedure and the studies that seem to show the existence of psi phenomena?" I think at this point if somebody had given him any aggro I would have jumped in. I think Jim might be a fellow woo and I am often motivated to defend my breathren if they are skepti-tacked. However, Kenny and Leighann gave him a factual and polite response. For those who don't know, the Ganzfeld method is the famous psi experiment where people sit in a red light with ping-pong balls over their eyes. It was actually this practice that led to the conversion of Susan Blackmore, see: https://hpanwo-voice.blogspot.com/2013/10/blackmores-ladyshave.html. I enjoyed this short lecture by Kenny and meant what I said in the comments about it being interesting. I always like to hear the other side of the story. I'll have to watch more of them... if I'm allowed to!
See here for background: https://hpanwo.blogspot.com/2021/08/skeptics-portal.html.

No comments:
Post a Comment