20,000 Leagues Under
the Sea, Jules Verne's classic proto-science fiction novel from 1870, has
been adapted numerous times; but the least faithful of these has just dropped. Nautilus, a Disney+ production, is a virtual
rewrite of the entire story. One of the attractions of the book is the author's
preservation of the mystery surrounding Nemo; a name which means
"nobody" in Latin. We know very little about him except he can speak
an unknown language and he is a great engineer, being the builder of the Nautilus as well as its captain. It is
only in the sequel/spin-off novel The
Mysterious Island that we find out he is Indian and of royal lineage. This
enigma is neutralized at the very start of the TV series. We are given Nemo's
life story in the opening scenes. The Nautilus
is not primarily built by him; instead it is the brainchild of a French
scientist called Benoit who claims to have been forced to work for the East
India Mercantile Company, although his story is questioned. Nemo himself is
reduced to a slave in the shipyard being pushed around and beaten by EEEEEEEvil
white Englishmen. Nemo steals the submarine during an uprising by the slaves and
manages to escape with Benoit and a handful of the other prisoners. He picks up
a few stragglers along the way, including a young woman called Humility, who
certainly does not live up to her name. She is a Mary Sue who knows everything
and can do everything, an icon of feminist perfection. She is accompanied by
her austere French governess called Loti. The rest of the makeshift crew are a
very international bunch of Africans, Indians, Chinese, a New Zealander and a
mysterious bearded bald guy who nobody knows anything about. They are pursued
by the Company who have a ship called Dreadnought
which is very similar to a real ship of that name from the beginning of the
20th century. Like Verne's novel, the series is set in the 1850's yet the
technology is about half a century ahead of its time; more so in the case of
the Nautilus sub. They also visit a
house with a refrigerator. This gives the series a distinct steampunk ambiance
that reminded me of Dune, see: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2024/07/dune-watchread-party-review.html.
The characters and their situation remind me a bit of Blakes 7, see: https://hpanwo.blogspot.com/2007/10/blakes-7.html.
The baddies are all typical white British imperialists which include Humility's
fiancé who is a spoilt and selfish aristocrat. They are cardboard cut-outs of white
colonialist monsters, straight out of the pages of Frantz Fanon, sporting charisma
in the minus figures. I'm surprised none of them wore monocles. There is a
slight exception when it comes to Billy Millais, an old schoolmate of Nemo's.
Humility is destined for an arranged marriage, but "breaks away!" to
study science at university; but she has to disguise herself as a man of course
because "Women!" are so "Oppressed!" Part of her disguise
is a false moustache... I'm not sure that would work in reality.
The programme has its good sides. There is one scene where
the submarine surfaces and the crew bribe some whalers not to kill some whales.
Whaling has always been something that evokes horror and heartbreak in me, for
some reason, and so I was inevitably drawn emotionally into that storyline.
Some of the characters are quite likeable. Nemo himself is a kind, intelligent
and courageous man, even though he is totally different in many ways from his
original literary namesake. He is played by Shazad Latif, best known for his
role in the TV programme Spooks. My
favourite character is probably Jagadish, an elderly Indian who professes
Marxist beliefs while seeking luxury wherever he can find it. He is an amiable
buffoon, but when danger strikes he shows a lot of loyalty and bravery. His
ending is tragic yet heroic. Even Humility develops and I warmed to her a bit
in later episodes. There is also a storyline involving mind control. There are
some amusing scenes, like when they have a 1914-style truce and the two sides
play a game, not of football but cricket; and they play it on the Arctic
icecap. As with Blakes 7, some of the
Nautilus crew are rather shady and
two-faced; and the viewer wonders which side they are really on. I was
interested in the submarine itself. This is described in great detail in the
book. At the time Verne was writing, submarines were very primitive and the inability
to invent a power source that didn't need air hampered their capabilities. This
problem was arguably only solved in the 1950's with the advent of nuclear
power. (Interestingly the first nuclear-powered sub was also called Nautilus.) In the book the sub is driven
by electricity generated from a sodium water machine. The sodium to fuel it is
mined on one of Nemo's islands. It is doubtful that such a system could ever
work because the reaction is too violent to release energy in a controlled
manner. It would be like trying to power a car with dynamite, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODf_sPexS2Q.
Several film adaptations have Nemo secretly inventing nuclear power, such as my
own favourite, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvrK4G6xKZQ.
In the case of the 2024 TV series the submarine has several additional features
that make sense. It has hydroplanes to change the boat's angle, a way of
extending or retracting the ram blades and armoured covers for the front
windows. She is armed with torpedoes as well as a ram that are fired from internal
reloadable tubes. But how is this Nautilus
powered? I was hoping there might be a free energy plotline to this
programme. I'd actually really welcome an adaptation of 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea with the submarine being driven by a
zero point power-plant. It would make perfect sense because free energy,
something like the Schauberger coil, would be the perfect propulsion system for
a submarine. It is air independent, requires no fuel and can deliver a very
high energy level for the volume and weight of its engine. My own fictional
work, Roswell Redeemed has this as
part of the story, see: https://hpanwo-bb.blogspot.com/2018/12/roswell-redeemed-is-here.html.
There is a tiny hint of such a plot element, especially at the end; and the
series is obviously intended to have a sequel. Despite all its positives, I
quickly grew tired of the show's anti-whiteness, its misandry. It was the
ruination of Star Trek, Star Wars and Doctor Who all over again. Despite my hopes that we had passed
"peak woke", the forces of mind-bending are not letting go of their
prey just like that. In one episode Nemo and Humility are arguing over who has
the most victimhood and in the same episode they meet a "Black!"
"Woman!" who used to be a slave on a sugarcane plantation. Game, set
and match I think. So generally I have mixed feelings about Nautilus, including regret that it could
have been so much better if they just cooled it with the white male historical
guilt trips. Source: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt15286302/.
See here for background: https://hpanwo.blogspot.com/2020/08/free-energy-portal.html.
See here for background: https://hpanwo.blogspot.com/2020/08/free-energy-portal.html.