I have come across an interesting film called Ex Machina which is thematically very
similar to Her, see: https://hpanwo-voice.blogspot.com/2025/06/her.html.
It is the directional debut for somebody better known as a novelist and
screenwriter, Alex Garland. It has an international cast and is also penned by Garland .
The story is about a nerdy and solitary young man called Caleb who works as a
coder for a major IT company. He wins a prize in the staff raffle which is a
week staying with the company's CEO at his luxury retreat in a remote location.
The place is beautiful, filmed in rural Norway .
The CEO is a furtive and shifty individual, somewhat older than Caleb. He is
also a functional alcoholic. He hints to Caleb that there's some big secret
going on in his laboratory, but he won't reveal the secret until Caleb signs
numerous non-disclosure agreements. Caleb eventually capitulates and finds out
that the CEO is working on humanoid robots with artificial intelligence and
wants Caleb to help him find out if these robots have consciousness. This is a
subject I've delved into many times and I suspect it is impossible to know
because one cannot tell the difference between real consciousness and a very
good mimic of consciousness unless you are
the entity being studied; in which case you will know with one hundred percent
certainty. This is the central message of Her
and also Ex Machina. There is a major
difference in the conclusion though, along with numerous plot twists and
double-twists. It explores the possibility of independent will in artificial
intelligence and the ability to deceive others. It's well worth watching. At
the moment it is on YouTube. This upload is seven years old so I assume it's
authorized, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQF8DmC4XK8.
See here for background: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2023/03/should-we-welcome-our-ai-overlords.html.
And: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2021/07/free-will.html.
See here for background: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2023/03/should-we-welcome-our-ai-overlords.html.
And: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2021/07/free-will.html.

Hi Ben, this is something that very much interests me and I will watch it. It's a subject I struggle to get my head around. Instinctively, I do not feel we should fear intelligence greater than our own. Observation can be a poor substitute for knowledge but our ecosysytem does seem to show us that a capacity for empathy increases with intelligence so you would hope that will also be true with machines. The best course of action is to treat it as conscious if it appears to be so. Always be polite and considerate to your AI assistant.
ReplyDeleteIt's odd you say that because I find myself saying "hello" and "thank you" to Grok and other AI's. I would feel very uncomfortable being abusive to it. Why, I ask myself? I'm personally far less afraid of AI than the very flesh and blood intelligence carriers that might use it as a tool of surveillance, manipulation and oppression against the population.
DeleteWatched it! Stunning film! Gets right to the heart of the issue and addresses the key concerns in the most poignant of ways. Nicely set up for a sequel or even a prequel.
ReplyDeleteBoth! I kept wondering how the laboratory started and what happened after Ava escapes.
Delete